I have to admit that in the past, I've only mildly been interested in lobster rolls. I am generally skeptical of anything that is bound together with mayonnaise (not particularly a favorite condiment of mine). I've had them in the past where they were too mayonnaise-y, with too many filler items or too mangled to discern that I was actually paying for lobster and not some processed pink/red product. I thought I might like the lobster rolls with butter instead but after trying that at Red's Eats in Maine, that was a bust as well.
But we were on the Cape this past weekend with Finn and I decided to give it another shot. After browsing the web a bit, we gave the roll at
Moby Dick's on Route 6 in Wellfleet a try. We were pleasantly surprised when the waitress brought to our table, a beautifully buttered and griddled bun filled with lobster chunks only barely licked by mayonnaise and dusted with paprika and with one leaf of lettuce between the meat and the bun. It was very tasty. The lobster was still mostly in chunks and the mayo did not overwhelm it.
The next day we headed back to Boston. On our way home, I wanted to try another lobster roll after the success at Moby Dick's. We hit the
Friendly Fisherman in Eastham. Wow! While I have limited experience, it was clearly the finest lobster roll I have ever eaten. It was so filled with lobster that I could barely find the bun. Again, the bun was beautifully buttered and griddled. The lobster was just kissed by mayo, enough to lightly dress it and actually accentuate the lobster's sweetness. The lobster meat itself was so fresh and succulent. It was perfectly cooked, tender with a wonderful briny sweetness. I could go on for days about how wonderful it was. Oh, yes... And they were actually really friendly there too.